My Car Is Paid For, Can I Deduct Ownership Expense on Means Test?

OWNERSHIP EXPENSE NOT ALLOWED IF VEHICLE PAID FOR
In re Howell, Case No. 06-11652
April 2007, Judge Nugent

Trustee objected to 13 confirmation under 1325(b)(1)(B) on basis that debtors projected disposable income was too low because they were deducted an ownership expense on Line 28 of B22C even though vehicle was fully paid for and even though they had claimed a standard vehicle operating allowance on Line 27. Objection Sustained, even though 707(b) (2) (A) (ii) (I) and B22C do not offer specific guidance.  Judge Nugent rejected the other view on the basis that an expense is not “applicable” if it is not actually incurred.

Digest by:  Jan Hamilton, Trustee

Related posts:

1. My Wife Didn't File Bankruptcy, Can I Deduct Her Car Payment on My Means Test?
2. Car Deduction Allowed on Means Test, Reversed by District Court
3. Nonworking Adult Son Not Counted in Household
4. Deduct Full Secured Debt on Bankruptcy Means Test
5. Topeka Debtors Allowed Means Test Deduction for Cars With No Liens